The Euro and stocks both gapped sharply up over the weekend on news that EU finance ministers are moving forward with a â‚¬100 billion Spanish bailout.
A few thoughts on this move:
- Where is the money coming from? (most EU Governments are broke)
- What precedent is this setting? (Ireland is already clamoring for a rewrite to its bailout rules)
- How desperate are things that theyâ€™re making such a large move so quickly?
Regarding this last point, Spanish political leaders have routinely denied needing a bailout for months. This whole bailout feels more than a little rushed given that Spain only formally requested a bailout (if you can even truly claim that) over the weekend: the same period during which a bailout was granted.
Moreover, itâ€™s very difficult to believe that this will â€œsolveâ€ Spainâ€™s problems. Let us consider the example of its recently nationalized bank, Bankia.
Bankia was formed in 2010 when the Spanish Government merged seven insolvent cajas (regional banks). In plain terms, Bankia was a trainwreck waiting to happenâ€¦ at least to anyone with a working brain. However, both the bank itself and the Spanish Government decided to maintain a charade that the bank was in great form right up until it collapsed (only one month ago Bankia was talking about paying its dividend).
Today, Bankia has been nationalized after its initial bailout request ballooned from â‚¬5 billion to â‚¬24 billion. Moreover, it has also revised its 2011 results from a â‚¬309 million profit to a â‚¬3 billion LOSS.
The point Iâ€™m making here is that both the Spanish Government and the Spanish Banks will play â€œextend and pretendâ€ as long as possible right up until theyâ€™re on the brink of collapse.
With that in mind, I sincerely doubt â‚¬100 billion is going to solve Spainâ€™s problems. The whole bailout reeks of desperation. And it likely will have political and financial implications that will quickly render the benefits of this move moot. Of course, when youâ€™re facing systemic collapse, you donâ€™t have time to debate implications and consequences. But I highly doubt that this move will do much to address Spainâ€™s true problems.
Indeed, stocks and the Euro are already coming off their over the weekend highs. This week will be critical for discerning the future of the markets. If risk assets remain aloft, then investors are still willing to believe that the Powers That Be can save/ maintain the markets.
But if stocks and the Euro tank this weekâ€¦ after a major bailout move such as thisâ€¦ then watch out, because the REAL Crisis has begun: the Crisis of faith in the actual financial system and the institutions meant to prop it up.
If this happens, then itâ€™s GAME OVER for the Euro at the very least.
While I hate to admit it, there is a good chance that this is indeed the more likely outcome. The Fed meets on June 19-20 so we could see risk assets remain afloat until then. But if Bernanke doesnâ€™t pull a rabbit out of a hat at that meeting then watch out because things could get very ugly very, very fast.